Wednesday, October 01, 2008

Vyvanse Warning Letter: Too Late! Shire Got Rid of Ty Pennington Long Ago!

By the time the FDA issues a warning letter about a DTC ad that violates FDA regulations -- as it did on September 25, 2008, for a video testimonial featuring Ty Pennington posted on youtube.com by Shire -- the cow has long left the barn.

The FDA letter -- which you can find here -- said "Both the webpage and video overstate the efficacy of Adderall XR; the video also omits important information regarding the risks associated with Adderall XR use. Additionally, the webpage broadens the indication for Adderall XR by suggesting uses that have not been approved by FDA. Thus, the webpage and video misbrand the drug in violation of the Federal Food, Drug, and Cosmetic Act..." blah, blah.

This is at least the second time recently that the FDA has cited an online video ad as violative. The first was a Pfizer Viagra video (see "Violative Viva Viagra Video - Still There!"). That video was misleading, said FDA, "because it makes representations and suggestions about the use of Viagra for erectile dysfunction, but fails to disclose any risk information for the drug." After the FDA letter to Pfizer became news, you could still see the video on its website, but now it is gone.

The Ty Pennington Adderall XR video can no longer be found on YouTube, which proves that Web 2.0 Tricks work! (see "Web 2.0 Pharma Marketing Tricks for Dummies"). I did, however, find another entertaining adult ADHD YouTube video, which you can find at the end of this post.

I am not sure when the Adderall XR YouTube video was removed, but I suspect it was long ago. First, Adderall XR was replaced by Vyvanse some time back. FDA must have known about this and probably wrote the letter before that happened. That it did not send the letter until September must mean that it was tied up in FDA's controversial internal legal review (see "FDA DTC Review: The House that Troy Built"), which allows violative ads to run uninterrupted until the media budget for the ads run out.

Not only that, I also notice that Ty Pennington is no longer the spokesperson for this drug as he was back in October, 2007 (see "J&J Blog, Shire PR: The Whole Story and Nothing But the Whole Story!"). I cannot find him on the Vyvanse website.

Ty Pennington Look-alike Ad
But Shire continues to use a Ty look-alike in print ads (a ploy similar to the "PC Guy" look-alike in Microsoft "I am a PC" TV ads). I found the following full-page Vyvanse ad in a recent issue of Time Magazine.

Clearly, Shire is milking the Ty Pennington franchise for all it's worth, but no longer paying the high celebrity endorsement fees. Maybe Ty did something to fall out of favor with Shire? Like switch over to shilling for Bayer aspirin? Could this be the "Linda Lovelace" Deep Throat effect?

Here's the Adult ADHD video:

6 comments:

  1. Anonymous12:23 PM

    Excellent youtube video!

    ReplyDelete
  2. Anonymous5:49 PM

    What you fail to point out is that even though the cow may have left the barn, the farmer has now locked the doors, thus preventing other cows from following the first.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I think the cows have the combination to the lock.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Anonymous2:11 AM

    Excellent points - especially about the fear of losing your creativity;
    You might find that you can actually settle down long enough to finish your project with a little medication!
    Because the ADD mind sees the world differently and processes solutions differently, the ADD mind is needed - it just needs a little help so it might manifest it's own uniqueness. Think about this: Why has the ADD mind not been weeded out in our evolution process? It's because - once again - the ADD mind is needed to help solve some if the situations we are in now!

    ReplyDelete
  5. Anonymous11:18 AM

    Insider Info...There was a photoshoot with Vyvanse with Ty Pennington for this very ad!...seems they chose to not use him for the ad and used the 'look alike' instead. Perhaps they don't want to be associated with Pennington.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Ha, Ha. Pretty funny!

    ReplyDelete